CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 7.5

Orb1 votes not in favor for the same reasoning as DRW. 

Hello Super Validator Node Owners,
 
Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote

https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/pull/53
 
Digital Asset - SV Sponsor
5North  - SV Endorser

All other's please list:

<SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor>

Dr. Amanda L. Martin
814-359-6544

The Linux Foundation

Director of Program Management

Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar

All - 

 

Following our discussion regarding this CIP, I wanted to present some modifications for the group to consider for subsequent vote.  If you would prefer I posted this in cip-discuss, please let me know and I will.  Given this proposal is in response to the original vote, I thought it most appropriate to post here.

Following the previous structure:

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NEW) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • 1.5 weight available during months 1-6 post integration with Canton.  0.25 weight available for each unique customer that settles > $125M of volume on Canton up to 1.5 weight total.
    • 1.0 weight available during months 7-12 post integration with Canton.  0.5 weight available for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
    • 1.5 weight available during months 13-24 post integration with Canton.  0.75 weight available for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total.

 

The total potential points for this structure is 7.5.

 

This approach does the following:

1. Maintains the integration incentive.
2. Introduces an incentive for exclusivity which we believe is merited for this type of integration.
3. Extends the adoption incentives timeline and increases the volume thresholds to align with longer-term, more material adoption.
4. Maintains participant diversity in the first 6 months of the adoption incentives, but pivots to just the notional threshold over the longer term to allow for a situation where a small number of customers significantly grows their utilization of Canton.  Seems like a good balance between diversity of adoption and depth of adoption.

 

We're very interested to hear the group's feedback so please chime in.  Ideally, assuming the group comes to consensus on this, we would be able to get feedback to ZH before the end of the week.

 

Thanks

Chris

 

Hi Chris,

Thanks for putting this together—Five North is supportive of the modifications.

I believe the tiered, stepwise incentive model and the 24-month timeframe align well with the network's goal 

and also provide ZeroHash sufficient space to drive volume as they scale their business. If they manage

to drive volume sooner, still great for everyone. 

Y.

On Tue, May 6, 2025 at 6:13 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:

All - 

 

Following our discussion regarding this CIP, I wanted to present some modifications for the group to consider for subsequent vote.  If you would prefer I posted this in cip-discuss, please let me know and I will.  Given this proposal is in response to the original vote, I thought it most appropriate to post here.

Following the previous structure:

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NEW) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • 1.5 weight available during months 1-6 post integration with Canton.  0.25 weight available for each unique customer that settles > $125M of volume on Canton up to 1.5 weight total.
    • 1.0 weight available during months 7-12 post integration with Canton.  0.5 weight available for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
    • 1.5 weight available during months 13-24 post integration with Canton.  0.75 weight available for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total.

 

The total potential points for this structure is 7.5.

 

This approach does the following:

1. Maintains the integration incentive.
2. Introduces an incentive for exclusivity which we believe is merited for this type of integration.
3. Extends the adoption incentives timeline and increases the volume thresholds to align with longer-term, more material adoption.
4. Maintains participant diversity in the first 6 months of the adoption incentives, but pivots to just the notional threshold over the longer term to allow for a situation where a small number of customers significantly grows their utilization of Canton.  Seems like a good balance between diversity of adoption and depth of adoption.

 

We're very interested to hear the group's feedback so please chime in.  Ideally, assuming the group comes to consensus on this, we would be able to get feedback to ZH before the end of the week.

 

Thanks

Chris

 

All - 

 

Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)

 

For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • Phase 1:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.5
      • "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
      • "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
      • Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
    • Phase 2:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.0
      •  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
      • For avoidance of doubt:
        • Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
        • This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
        • Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
    • Phase 3:
      • Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
      • Available Weight: 1.5 weight
      • 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
      • For the avoidance of doubt:
        • This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
        • The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.

 

This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.

thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis 

Looks like a positive construct to me

@ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?

On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:

All - 

 

Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)

 

For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • Phase 1:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.5
      • "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
      • "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
      • Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
    • Phase 2:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.0
      •  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
      • For avoidance of doubt:
        • Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
        • This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
        • Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
    • Phase 3:
      • Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
      • Available Weight: 1.5 weight
      • 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
      • For the avoidance of doubt:
        • This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
        • The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.

 

This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.

--

W. Eric Saraniecki

Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983

Digital Asset, creators of Daml

This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.

Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.  

Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote. 

On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:26 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:

thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis 

Looks like a positive construct to me

@ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?

On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:

All - 

 

Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)

 

For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • Phase 1:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.5
      • "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
      • "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
      • Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
    • Phase 2:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.0
      •  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
      • For avoidance of doubt:
        • Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
        • This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
        • Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
    • Phase 3:
      • Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
      • Available Weight: 1.5 weight
      • 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
      • For the avoidance of doubt:
        • This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
        • The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.

 

This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.

--

W. Eric Saraniecki

Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983

Digital Asset, creators of Daml

This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.

Hi Amanda - can you change the email and header as the total weight is now 7.5 (I believe) please ?

On May 10, 2025, at 7:01 AM, DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global <amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:



Hello Super Validator Node Owners,
 
Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote on the second proposal

https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/blob/cip-0060/cip-0060/cip-0060.md

Digital Asset - SV Sponsor
5North  - SV Endorser

All other's please list:

<SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor>

Dr. Amanda L. Martin
814-359-6544

The Linux Foundation

Director of Program Management

Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar

On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 1:27 AM Chris Matturri via lists.sync.global <chris=proofgroup.xyz@...> wrote:

Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.  

Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote. 

On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:26 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:

thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis 

Looks like a positive construct to me

@ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?

On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:

All - 

 

Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)

 

For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.

 

 

• (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
  • Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
  • Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
• (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
  • Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
• (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
  • Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
  • Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
  • Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
  • Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
• (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
  • Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
  • Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
  • Details:
    • Phase 1:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.5
      • "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
      • "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
      • Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
    • Phase 2:
      • Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
      • Available Weight: 1.0
      •  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
      • For avoidance of doubt:
        • Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
        • This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
        • Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
    • Phase 3:
      • Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
      • Available Weight: 1.5 weight
      • 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
      • For the avoidance of doubt:
        • This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
        • The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.

 

This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.

--

W. Eric Saraniecki

Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983

Digital Asset, creators of Daml

This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.

This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.

Hi all - I'm confused so please excuse me.

Are we moving forward with this as a fresh vote or
we just wait for the rest of the SVs to vote?

Thanks.

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 2:54 AM DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global
<amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>
> Thanks for letting me know. All changed!
>
> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
> 814-359-6544
> The Linux Foundation
> Director of Program Management
> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>
>
> On Sat, May 10, 2025 at 1:21 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Amanda - can you change the email and header as the total weight is now 7.5 (I believe) please ?
>>
>>
>>
>> On May 10, 2025, at 7:01 AM, DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global <amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>>
>> 
>> Hello Super Validator Node Owners,
>>
>> Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote on the second proposal
>>
>> https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/blob/cip-0060/cip-0060/cip-0060.md
>>
>> Digital Asset - SV Sponsor
>> 5North  - SV Endorser
>>
>> All other's please list:
>>
>> <SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor>
>>
>>
>> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
>> 814-359-6544
>> The Linux Foundation
>> Director of Program Management
>> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>>
>>
>> On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 1:27 AM Chris Matturri via lists.sync.global <chris=proofgroup.xyz@...> wrote:
>>>
>>> Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.
>>>
>>> Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote.
>>>
>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:26 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis
>>>>
>>>> Looks like a positive construct to me
>>>>
>>>> @ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> All -
>>>>>
>>>>> Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)
>>>>>
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
>>>>> Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
>>>>> Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>> Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
>>>>>
>>>>> (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
>>>>> Details:
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 1:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5
>>>>> "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
>>>>> "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
>>>>> Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 2:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.0
>>>>>  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
>>>>> This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
>>>>> Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 3:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5 weight
>>>>> 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
>>>>> For the avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
>>>>> The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> W. Eric Saraniecki
>>>> Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983
>>>> Digital Asset, creators of Daml
>>>>
>>>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>>
>>
>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>
>

We are conducting a new vote since this is resubmitted. 

So far the voting is below, I logged your vote even though it technical happened before it opened again :)

Proof Group - in favor

Digital Asset - Sponsor

5North - Endorser

Dr. Amanda L. Martin
814-359-6544

The Linux Foundation

Director of Program Management

Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar

On Tue, May 13, 2025 at 5:15 PM Yiannis Varelas via lists.sync.global <y=fivenorth.io@...> wrote:

Hi all - I'm confused so please excuse me.

Are we moving forward with this as a fresh vote or
we just wait for the rest of the SVs to vote?

Thanks.

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 2:54 AM DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global
<amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>
> Thanks for letting me know. All changed!
>
> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
> 814-359-6544
> The Linux Foundation
> Director of Program Management
> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>
>
> On Sat, May 10, 2025 at 1:21 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Amanda - can you change the email and header as the total weight is now 7.5 (I believe) please ?
>>
>>
>>
>> On May 10, 2025, at 7:01 AM, DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global <amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>>
>> 
>> Hello Super Validator Node Owners,
>>
>> Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote on the second proposal
>>
>> https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/blob/cip-0060/cip-0060/cip-0060.md
>>
>> Digital Asset - SV Sponsor
>> 5North  - SV Endorser
>>
>> All other's please list:
>>
>> <SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor>
>>
>>
>> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
>> 814-359-6544
>> The Linux Foundation
>> Director of Program Management
>> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>>
>>
>> On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 1:27 AM Chris Matturri via lists.sync.global <chris=proofgroup.xyz@...> wrote:
>>>
>>> Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.
>>>
>>> Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote.
>>>
>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:26 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis
>>>>
>>>> Looks like a positive construct to me
>>>>
>>>> @ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> All -
>>>>>
>>>>> Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)
>>>>>
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
>>>>> Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
>>>>> Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>> Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
>>>>>
>>>>> (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
>>>>> Details:
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 1:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5
>>>>> "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
>>>>> "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
>>>>> Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 2:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.0
>>>>>  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
>>>>> This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
>>>>> Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 3:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5 weight
>>>>> 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
>>>>> For the avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
>>>>> The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> W. Eric Saraniecki
>>>> Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983
>>>> Digital Asset, creators of Daml
>>>>
>>>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>>
>>
>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>
>

Cumberland DRW votes in favor.

 

From: cip-vote@... <cip-vote@...> On Behalf Of DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global
Sent: Tuesday, May 13, 2025 10:17 AM
To: cip-vote@...
Subject: [ext] Re: [cip-votes] CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 7.5

 

We are conducting a new vote since this is resubmitted. So far the voting is below, I logged your vote even though it technical happened before it opened again :) Proof Group - in favor Digital Asset - Sponsor 5North - Endorser Dr. Amanda L. 

We are conducting a new vote since this is resubmitted. 

 

So far the voting is below, I logged your vote even though it technical happened before it opened again :)

 

Proof Group - in favor

Digital Asset - Sponsor

5North - Endorser

 

 

Dr. Amanda L. Martin
814-359-6544

The Linux Foundation

Director of Program Management

Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar

 

 

On Tue, May 13, 2025 at 5:15 PM Yiannis Varelas via lists.sync.global <y=fivenorth.io@...> wrote:

Hi all - I'm confused so please excuse me.

Are we moving forward with this as a fresh vote or
we just wait for the rest of the SVs to vote?

Thanks.

On Mon, May 12, 2025 at 2:54 AM DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global
<amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>
> Thanks for letting me know. All changed!
>
> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
> 814-359-6544
> The Linux Foundation
> Director of Program Management
> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>
>
> On Sat, May 10, 2025 at 1:21 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>
>> Hi Amanda - can you change the email and header as the total weight is now 7.5 (I believe) please ?
>>
>>
>>
>> On May 10, 2025, at 7:01 AM, DrAmandaLMartin via lists.sync.global <amartin=linuxfoundation.org@...> wrote:
>>
>> 
>> Hello Super Validator Node Owners,
>>
>> Please find CIP-0060: Add Zero Hash as SV of Weight 10 ready for vote on the second proposal
>>
>> https://github.com/global-synchronizer-foundation/cips/blob/cip-0060/cip-0060/cip-0060.md
>>
>> Digital Asset - SV Sponsor
>> 5North  - SV Endorser
>>
>> All other's please list:
>>
>> <SV Name> votes <in favor | not in favor>
>>
>>
>> Dr. Amanda L. Martin
>> 814-359-6544
>> The Linux Foundation
>> Director of Program Management
>> Github  | LinkedIn  | Calendar
>>
>>
>> On Fri, May 9, 2025 at 1:27 AM Chris Matturri via lists.sync.global <chris=proofgroup.xyz@...> wrote:
>>>
>>> Thank you Chris & Yiannis- appreciate you guys speaking with Ed to get these changes over the line.
>>>
>>> Aligns well with their volume + customer onboarding incentives.  Proof Group will support this with our vote.
>>>
>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:26 PM Eric Saraniecki via lists.sync.global <eric=digitalasset.com@...> wrote:
>>>>
>>>> thank you Zuehlke & Yiannis
>>>>
>>>> Looks like a positive construct to me
>>>>
>>>> @ Amanda - would you please update the CIP and then we can proceed with the vote?
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> On Thu, May 8, 2025 at 5:23 PM Chris Zuehlke via lists.sync.global <czuehlke=drwholdings.com@...> wrote:
>>>>>
>>>>> All -
>>>>>
>>>>> Yiannis and I had a chance to speak with Edward from ZH earlier today and talked through the proposal changes.  He shared some feedback, portions of which I think merit some changes to what I proposed a few days ago.  Based on his feedback, I believe they are ready to accept the following (including the standard KPI/escrow structure, etc.)
>>>>>
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt, I reposted each of the elements but the only changes are in Adoptions Incentives  Similar principles and numbers, but some modified constructs on how to establish the thresholds.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Zero Hash ("ZH") Product Integration to Canton:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH integrates Canton Coin and USDC issued on Canton into their product suite, may include other Canton based assets at their sole discretion.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 2.5
>>>>> Note: May need to consider starting the timeline around when natively issued USDC is available.
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Education, Social, and Events:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH conducts at least on of each by the deadline (Webinar, White Paper, Social Media Amplification, Joint Event).
>>>>> Deadline: +90 days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>>
>>>>> (NO CHANGE) Canton is the Exclusive Privacy-enabled Settlement Blockchain for ZH:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance Criteria: ZH exclusively leverages Canton for privacy-enabled on-chain settlement whenever technically possible.
>>>>> Deadline: +180 day days from CIP approval
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 0.5
>>>>> Note: We used the "technically possible" language to address situations where an asset isn't available on Canton but aren't particularly attached to that clause.
>>>>>
>>>>> (MODIFIED) Adoption Incentives:
>>>>>
>>>>> Acceptance and Deadlines: described below.
>>>>> Potential Weight Earned: 4.0
>>>>> Details:
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 1:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 6th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5
>>>>> "Unlock Criteria": ZH onboards 6 customers across at least 2 different use cases from the below list (one of which must be payment processors/providers) and each of those customers conducts at least $10M in on-chain transactions.
>>>>> "Earn Criteria": Provided the Unlock Criteria is met, they earn 0.25 weight for each $125M notional volume their customers transact on mainnet up to 1.5 weight/$750M notional.
>>>>> Use Case Verticals: Retails Wallet Providers, Payment Processors/Providers, Payroll Providers, and Fund/Trading.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 2:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the first day of solution live on mainnet until the end of the 12th month afterwards.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.0
>>>>>  0.5 weight is earned for every $500M of volume settled on Canton up to 1.0 weight total.
>>>>> For avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> Yes, this does overlap with Phase 1
>>>>> This volume must be above and beyond the first 750M from Phase 1.  The count would start at $750,000,001.
>>>>> Their earn could start in month 1 if they quickly exceed the $750M from Phase 1.
>>>>>
>>>>> Phase 3:
>>>>>
>>>>> Timeline: From the months 13-24 after the solution is live on mainnet.
>>>>> Available Weight: 1.5 weight
>>>>> 0.75 weight earned for every $1B of volume settled on Canton up to 1.5 weight total
>>>>> For the avoidance of doubt:
>>>>>
>>>>> This volume is independent from Phase 1 and Phase 2 as there is no timing overlap.
>>>>> The volume counter starts at 0 and begins incrementing with the first transaction conducted as of month 13.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> This maintains the diversity and duration the group was interested in, but provides ZH a little more flexibility in places.  Please share any questions/thoughts.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> --
>>>> W. Eric Saraniecki
>>>> Co-founder / +1 773 719 1983
>>>> Digital Asset, creators of Daml
>>>>
>>>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>>
>>
>> This message, and any attachments, is for the intended recipient(s) only, may contain information that is privileged, confidential and/or proprietary and subject to important terms and conditions available at http://www.digitalasset.com/emaildisclaimer.html. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete this message.
>
>

This e-mail and any attachments may contain information that is confidential and proprietary and otherwise protected from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient of this e-mail, do not read, duplicate or redistribute it by any means. Please immediately delete it and any attachments and notify the sender that you have received it by mistake. Unintended recipients are prohibited from taking action on the basis of information in this e-mail or any attachments. The DRW Companies make no representations that this e-mail or any attachments are free of computer viruses or other defects.